Concierge Medicine - Another Option For Primary Care Practices

Concierge medicine was in the news again today.properly covered.
Concierge medicine is not yet a widespreadOne line of attack against concierge medicine is that it
phenomenon, but has been increasing in popularity asis acting as a form of insurance, and concierge
primary care doctors find it increasingly difficult topractices are in effect operating as an unlicensed
provide attentive care to their patients, and maintain ainsurance company. It is still too early to be sure how
worthwhile lifestyle at the same time. For thosethis will play out, but these arguments miss the overall
unfamiliar with the concept of concierge medicine, itpoint that the concierge medicine trend illustrates.
works as follows: doctors charge each patient anIs healthcare a fundamental right? Or is it a service
annual retainer. The fees vary, but $1000-3500/yrprovided by professionals with fees set by market
appears to be a commonly quoted range. In return forforces? If it is the former, than a national health
this, the patient receives 24/7/365 access to thesystem, or a private system with a foolproof 'safety
practice via email, cell phone, etc. They receive on-timenet' for those unable to afford private care, makes
appointments without delay, and appointments are notsense. If it is the latter, than concierge medicine reflects
the typical 10 minute one so common to rushedan effort by private-sector primary care to provide this
primary-care practices today.service in a fashion that makes more sense than the
Not surprisingly, concierge medicine has generatedcurrent system does.
debate as to whether this system is 'fair' for patientsThe system has not determined what the answer to
who are unable to afford the retainers. Also, it must bethis question is, although it is clear that the
pointed out that concierge medicine is not insurance.administration as well as many prominent politicians,
That is, patients will still be responsible for othersuch as the late Sen. Kennedy, believe that it is a right.
healthcare services such as hospitalizations, surgery,For now, individual providers are deciding for
diagnostic imaging, etc. Concierge patients need tothemselves, and adjusting their own terms of
maintain their regular health insurance in order to beparticipation in the system.